Kristen Wiig
Imogene
Annette Bening
Zelda
Matt Dillon
George
Darren Criss
Lee
Christopher Fitzgerald
Ralph
June Diane Raphael
Dara
Natasha Lyonne
Allyson
Bob Balaban
Maxwell
Sydney Lucas
Little Imogene
Jimmy Palumbo
Doorman Joe
Michelle Morgan
Georgina
Mickey Sumner
Hannah
Elizabeth Inghram
Sloane
Brian Petsos
Peter Van Woodsen
Murray Bartlett
James Whitney
Melissa Navia
Assistant
Michelle Hurd
Libby
Jennifer Fox
Hotel Clerk
Cynthia Nixon
Cynthia Nixon
Reed Birney
Dr. Chalmers
Manny Siverio
Gino
Nnamdi Nwosa
Bruce
Clare Galterio
Announcer
Akira Takayama
Casino Gambler
Helmar Augustus Cooper
Delancey Security Guard
Tandy Cronyn
Hermione
Nicole Patrick
Monica
Bronson
Hermit Crab
Nate Corddry
Larry Feinstein
Mike Keller
NJ Cop / T-Rex Rinaldi
Henriette Mantel
Female Police Officer
Antwayn Hopper
Emcee
Katie Webber
Britney Spears / Charlotte
Jonathan M. Cooper
Backstreet Boy #1
Felix Hess
Backstreet Boy #2
Jake Dupree
Backstreet Boy #3
Ian Klein
Backstreet Boy #4
Jonny Orsini
Nick
Julia Macchio
Lucy
Emma Myles
Hippie Girl
Padma Lakshmi
Padma Lakshmi
Frank Pando
NYPD Police Officer #1
Daniella van Graas
Cecille
Aliya Carter
NYPD Police Officer #2
Betty Hudson
Housekeeper
Ronald Guttman
Armando
Mike Gillman
Male Anchor
Jessica Abo
Michelle Connors
Julia Stiles
Stage Imogene
Andrea Martin
Stage Zelda
Graeme Malcolm
Culture Vulture
Whit Stillman
Whit Stillman
Patricia Kalember
Virginia
Marceline Hugot
Librarian
Ilana Levine
Teacher